Perceptions of women online are stuck in the Dark Ages

email article email article print article print article tip @techmeme

We have a real obsession with labels in our society. We like to put people into nice little boxes and categories, so we can package them, pop them on a mental shelf, and not worry about them. And we tend to do this far more with women than with men. The ancient literary trope of “maiden, mother, crone” seems to be alive and kicking online. And I, for one, am sick of it.

A literary metaphor for representations of the female online may seem a little academic, but I believe this has serious ramifications in the real world. The internet is essentially a modern literary realm. The profiles we have online — be they websites, blogs, social media profiles — are representations of self, created primarily through words (with a few pictures thrown in for good measure). We are constructing our identities, often on a daily basis. We make choices, constantly, without really giving them a lot of consideration. What pages we “like”, what links we share, what we write in our bio, which issues we comment on.

I believe that while the internet is supposedly a democratic medium, women are — whether through peer pressure, or their own choice — grouped into the three ancient stereotypes of women, while men move freely through a myriad of identities. If you don’t believe me, read a little further. Chances are that most of the women you know could be lumped into one of the three descriptors.

Ok, so maiden has moved rather more into the realm of, to use that highly debated word, “slut”. It’s been estimated that 12 percent of the internet is porn. As Caitlin Moran points out in “How to be a Woman“, “this is clearly as unhappy and detrimental to women’s collective peace of mind as it would be if 12 percent of images of men on the internet were of them having their heads horrifically blown off by alien laser guns, or being lowered down a well, full of Nazi sharks, crying”.

Neither she nor I are against porn as a concept, but the sheer harsh proliferation of it, and the nature of the imagery of women involved, makes me very sad. And that’s not even counting the, for want of a better term, “non-porn” which involves scantily clad women or attempts to lure us to the porn. Beyond that, the single women of my acquaintance are far more likely to have profile pictures or avatars of their cleavage, them in bikinis, or other sexy poses than the single men of my acquaintance. “Being sexy” is a clearly acceptable attribute for a woman to promote online.

And that might work for some, who are sexy, who say screw it, I might as well use this to my advantage. Again, I am not opposed to being sexy. I appreciate it. But I worry when sexy becomes “sex object”. When a woman becomes not a woman who is “sexy and funny and” but a “sexy woman”. Other terms for maiden these days are “chicks” and “girls”.

And so to the mothers. Or, as tech writers love to call them, “mommybloggers“. The term actually makes me grind my teeth, which any mommyblogger worth their salt would tell you is a bad idea.

Every couple of months people write about how “the moms” have “taken over” some aspect of the internet — recently, the moms took over Google+, apparently. I don’t have anything against moms. Or bloggers. I am always the former and occasionally the latter. But we would never classify fathers online with such a simple sweeping phrase. On all the social networks, the mothers gather, and any passing remark about your children sees you being classified by several people as such. When did mothers become a class of human to the exclusion of all else?

Firstly, isn’t that a tad bloody insulting to all the fathers out there? All those “mom and me” or “mom’s circle” groups and networks — why are we perpetuating the belief that parenting is purely a mother’s domain? It seems these days it’s no longer “children should be seen and not heard”.

Instead it’s become “children should be seen in cute photographs but not really heard about”. The separation of children from mainstream society, and the separation of the “mom” part of an identity from the rest of a woman’s identity is frankly unhealthy. Again, I’m bloody proud to be a mom, but I would be grateful if I were given the same allowances as men that go gaga over their offspring every so often: that it is one element of my identity, not an all-encompassing-full-time-at-the-exclusion-of-all-else job description.

Other terms for moms? Nope. That’s part of the problem.

The third female stereotype is a little harder to grasp. Ah, the crone. Or, to put it another way, the bitchy, gripey, moany, sarcastic, and generally pretty darn fun persona that women who are neither maidens nor mothers frequently assume.

Although technically connected with age, there are several women in their twenties to take it upon themselves to be crones. This is an attitude which comes naturally to several women. We are a little cynical about the world. We like to be a little “one of the lads”, throw around some sarcasm. Ooh, look how much I’m saying “we” and identifying with this persona. There’s a darker side though. Once you’ve established yourself in this mould, it’s hard to have soft, silly moments. Hard to make serious comment on serious issues without being viewed as that nastier side of the crone — the harridan. The line between funny bitchy and sad bitchy is a fine line indeed.

So what exactly is my problem again? My problem is that most women I know have elements of all the above. As indeed do most men. My problem is that while men can just be themselves online, women, whether through their own volition, perceived peer pressure, or just communal laziness, tend to settle into one of the personas above.

I am a maiden, mother, and crone. Frequently all at the same time. I’m also a geek, a thespian, a pedant, a couch potato, and a million other things besides. And that’s all just one woman. Imagine, if we start exploding these stereotypes, what we might become?

email article email article print article print article

  • http://walterpike.com Walter Pike

    Yes I think that you are right, although online is not another world and your commentary is a commentary on society and roles that people play. The generalisation of people into groups because of gender or race and such like criteria is also useless. 

    You don’t mention the word ‘Slut” which is interesting because its been such a topic of conversation lately with #slutwalkjhb taking place on the 24/9 the process it represents on the surface is highlighting victim blaming – but underlying it is a similar comment on society. 

    The reclaiming of the word slut is in itself removing exactly the generalisation and patriarchy you allude to. I need declare that I am an organiser of the event so its very much on my mind – It was surprising to me that the attitudes towards woman are not only gender based – in fact many woman are hard wired into patriarchal attitudes and accepting and therefore perpetuating these medieval attitudes – which I think is what you are saying.

  • http://www.facebook.com/people/Dani-Cass/1217963149 Dani Cass

    So women are either sluts, bitches or mums? I disagree. Yes there are these types of women but there are many others. 

    To be honest, it’s articles like this that encourage people to pigeon-hole women.

  • http://www.facebook.com/people/Dani-Cass/1217963149 Dani Cass

    So women are either sluts, bitches or mums? I disagree. Yes there are these types of women but there are many others. 

    To be honest, it’s articles like this that encourage people to pigeon-hole women.

  • http://www.facebook.com/people/Dani-Cass/1217963149 Dani Cass

    So women are either sluts, bitches or mums? I disagree. Yes there are these types of women but there are many others. 

    To be honest, it’s articles like this that encourage people to pigeon-hole women.

  • Guest

    Shut up and make me a sandwhich.

  • Guest

    Shut up and make me a sandwhich.

  • Icedog_0

    This is why women don’t leave the kitchen. Seriously. That’s not just a label. You need to shut up and stop fighting for rights you already have.

  • Icedog_0

    This is why women don’t leave the kitchen. Seriously. That’s not just a label. You need to shut up and stop fighting for rights you already have.

  • Poes

    no, you are quite simply a retard

  • Plastiek

    The day women stop labelling each other is the day men will stop labelling them too. Women are their own worst enemy.

Related Articles on the Web

Related articles

Topics for this article

[ advertising enquiries ]

Share
  • BURN MEDIA TV

    WATCH THE LATEST EPISODE NOW
    Latest Episode
    Sony Xperia Z2 Review

MORE HEADLINES

news

VIEW MORE

interviews

VIEW MORE

future trends

VIEW MORE

entrepreneurship

VIEW MORE

social media

VIEW MORE

facebook

VIEW MORE

twitter

VIEW MORE

google

VIEW MORE

advertising & marketing

VIEW MORE

online media

VIEW MORE

design

VIEW MORE

mobile

VIEW MORE

More in Online media

On aggregating and rewriting: It's all a steal!

Read More »
Link